DOZENS of demonstrators gathered at the entrance of County Hall this morning [Thursday, November 19] with banners and gas masks to protest against development and dredging in Falmouth Harbour.
The protesters sang and handed out information to those entering the building, before sitting in the public gallery to hear a meeting of the strategic planning committee to discuss an application to carry out work at the dock.
More than 700 submissions opposing the plans have been made via Cornwall Council’s planning portal, and over 5,000 people have signed a petition protesting against the dredge, claiming it could do severe damage to the Carrick Roads marine ecosystem including protected habitats and local fisheries.
The meeting itself concerned not the dredging but an application for the demolition of on-site buildings, partial demolition of existing wharf structures, construction of new wharf structures and other related construction works, lay down area for floating wind power activities (FLOW), temporary construction area, and ancillary works associated with the redevelopment and modernisation of the existing Falmouth dock infrastructure. These plans were approved by seven votes to three against.
The dredging was not under discussion due to that application being subject to a licence from the Marine Management Organisation (MMO). However, it was often mentioned, and committee chairman Chris Batters regularly had to call for calm in the public gallery.
Speaking outside County Hall, former Falmouth town councillor Zoe Young said: “The committee that is meeting today has not received all the information that’s relevant to the decision. There are multiple material planning considerations outstanding that we are here to draw their attention to, because their officers have given a recommendation of approval. They are going to opening themselves up to a lot of legal challenges.”
Tom Scott, Green Party coordinator and Falmouth resident, said: “We would really like to emphasise that we are not against the modernisation of the docks but want it to be done in a safe and responsible way which doesn’t threaten the marine environment.
“Cornwall Wildlife Trust has explained that one of the main problems is they simply don’t know without more sampling how toxic the spoil is. It will be dredged just outside an area of protected habitat, and that’s liable to do a great deal of damage to the marine ecology.
“Essentially what the planning officers have done is make a judgement that the benefits of the scheme outweigh the harm it will do. We feel that is completely wrong.”
Locals are also concerned about the impact of a massive expansion of cruise-ship tourism on air pollution, traffic congestion and quality of life in Falmouth.
“[The scheme] has ignored some crucial harms, one of the biggest being air pollution caused by bringing in much bigger cruise ships with a huge amount of emissions and particulates known to be harmful to human health,” said Mr Scott.
“A lot of people are concerned about the doubling of passenger numbers to 200,000 a year. Most will not be spending a huge amount of money in Falmouth but will be bussed to other attractions in Cornwall, putting pressure on the traffic system.”
Chris Ranger, a native oyster fisherman based at Mylor harbour, said: “The dredging could decimate marine life, not just my livelihood. The impact on tourism could also be catastrophic - boats will no longer see dolphins and seals. The biggest justification seems to be creation of jobs, but there’s no guarantee Falmouth will get those kids of contracts.”
Students Zennor Tyndal-Biscoe and Mahni Clear had missed lessons to attend the event. “I’m skipping college this morning because the decisions they make now will affect our community,” said Truro College student Zennor, 17. “It’s important our voices are heard.”
Mahni, 20, who is studying global sustainability at the University of Exeter’s Penryn campus, referenced the documentary film All Rivers Spill Their Stories to the Sea, about pollution which decimated shellfish in the River Tees. “It’s a poignant moment to think it could happen here,” he said.



.jpeg?width=209&height=140&crop=209:145,smart&quality=75)

Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.